Friday, August 6, 2010

The business plan: who is the competition

The company competes with large and small manufacturers of performace racing bicycle frame sets that sell to the high end of the market through independent bike stores (IBS) and on line.  The company will have its work cut out competing with these companies given the size, resources and brand name recognition of its competitors. However, the company beleives that it will able to compete for the following reasons. First, the company is scaling out distribution by working with independent bike stores (IBS) using the agency model rather than the traditional distribution model. Second, the company scales out production to More Choice, Inc. in Taiwan (an eventually to others) which is able to provide quality carbon frames in much lower volumes and on shorter notice than the larger contract manufacturers. Third, the company provides frames to its IBS agents when the IBS agents have a customer who is ready to buy one rather than requiring distributors to take delivery of an inventory of built up bicycles months in advance. Finally, the company uses mass production techniques to create economies of scale in delivering the frames to its IBS agents and thus allows the IBS to implement measures that create economies of scale in assembly of the bikes.

In more simple terms, the company concentrates its resources on providing high quality road racing frames (not completely built up bicycles) to the "I want it right" market rather than competing in the "I want it now" market which is saturated and dominated by the big manufacturers. The company's business model allows the consumer to use the Internet to make choices and to place orders, but the company does not try to cut out the IBS. The company beleives that most consumers are still going to need the IBS for some services or they will want the community that is associated with the IBS; the company also beleives that the opinion of the IBS about a brand matters a lot. Additionally, the company beleives that it will be able to restore an old premium road frame brand for its frames which will differentiate the company from existing brands, complement the inventory of brands that the IBS offers and allow the company to introduce this new business model to the market. The company recognizes that it is not in a position to innovate frame technology and will leave that to the manufacturers in Asia who are clearly more skilled at such things. However, the company can innovate the processes of bicycle production, distribution and delivery in such a way that all parties benefit.

Thursday, August 5, 2010

Scaling out distribution: The Unilever way

The most common example of scaling out distribution is the ice cream truck or, as seen in Thailand, the fish truck. The ice cream truck in the US drives around suburbia playing The Entertainer through a loudspeaker; the children here the music and come running. In Jakarta, the Walls Ice Cream cart plys the narrow streets playing an unforgettable melody with similar effect (Walls Ice Cream is owned by Unilever).  Frames and Wheels rode through a remote town in the hills to the east of Chiang Mai and saw the fish truck: this is a pick up truck with ice coolers in the back full of fish and a large loudspeaker on the roof of the cab through which the driver broadcasts at startling high volume the selection of his inventory (Frames and Wheels saw the cat fish truck). These forms of distribution are common in emerging markets because of poor distribution networks, the remoteness of markets and perhaps poor infrastructure or transportation alternatives that prevent the customer from coming to market.

There is another example from Uilever, the consumer products company. In remote villages in India, the company appoints individuals to become dealers as well as educators for their products. The way Frames and Wheels understands it, there is a distribution point near a target market. But the target market is so remote or impenetratable that selling through traditional kiosks is too costly or difficult. Consequnetly, the company hires the people who use the product the most: in the case of detergent, it is women who run households. These women act as ambassadors for the product and convince their friends and acquaintenaces to use the product too. It is the Avon Lady model, but instead of cosmetics, it is household products. This is a great example of scaling out distribution. Applying this model or something like it to bicycle frames is one that Frames and Wheels will mull over and explore in a later post.


Tuesday, August 3, 2010

The business plan: who will buy

The buyer of the company's frames are independnet bike stores (IBS) that serve the dedicated amateur cyclist nationwide. The target IBS is located in cities, it has high income, masters cyclists as customers who are "I want it right" rather than "I want it now" consumers; it has accounts with high end component and wheel manufacturers; retains knowedgeable staff and supports amatuer racing among other things. The company seeks to complement the brand selection of an IBS with a choice that is high quality, good value and customized for the consumer and profitable and low risk for the IBS. The company does not envisage selling frames directly to consumers because the consumer will always need and want the support of the IBS. Additionally, the company will always need and want the goodwill and support of the IBS. The company is not trying to cut out the IBS from the market; rather the company seeks to help the IBS reduce its risk and better serve its customers using the principals of frugal innovation. The fundamental difference between the company and other manufacturers is that the company does this by retaining the IBS to be an agent of the company's brand. This allows the IBS to better match supply with demand and liberates the IBS from buying a dozen fully built bicycles up front months in advance.

Motobecane rider at the Catskills

Frames and Wheels met a rider at the Tour of the Catskills bike race over the weekend and learned a lot about why consumers buy these frames on line. This rider was an experienced racer, but he was entering the one day "Assault on Devil's Kitchen" stage; he did not enter the entire race because he knew his fitness was not high enough. He was I think entering the Category Five (35 plus) race or had done so in the past. He was very pleasant and more than happy to talk, which is generally the case for most cyclists when it comes to discussing their bikes. His first name is Ad and I think he is from Scandanavia (but residing in New Jersey).

Ad said that he had heard of Motobecane, but it was not the brand he set out to obtain. It sounded like he was looking for value.  He read reviews about the brand and the bike on line and learned that reviews were generally favorable (although Frames and Wheels had heard less favourable reviews from bike stores, and read some pretty awful reviews on line. But perhaps they are improving their game). He was aware of the background of the company: a business man from Texas had acquired the rights to the brand and others and retained Kinesis, a Taiwanese manufacturer, to make the bikes; he did not seem to have a problem with this. The bikes are assembled in Taiwan and sold directly to consumers on line for pretty competitive prices (no overhead, labor or rent factored into the price). I think Ad had the Motobecane Immortal Ice. I am not sure about components, but I think it was Ultegra; he had a carbon Zipp wheel on the back and a carbon American Classic on the front. Ad had done a lot of customization to the bike. This bike retails for $3,400 when built up with Simano Ultegra 6700 and Mavic wheels.

Ad mentioned that the pricing on the bike was very good; he described a sentiment that Frames and Wheels has heard before: he could order the bike, take all the components off the bike and sell them on eBay and then build up the remaining carbon frame with his own components. Assuming that he could get about $800 for the unused groupset and $400 for the wheels, his cost for the frame would be lowered to $2,200. Frames and Wheels thinks that this is a bit high for 2.7 pound frameset with a somewhat tainted brand, but it is clear that consumers are willing unbundle bikes to save money and get what they want.  Frames and Wheels has also heard of people ordering a Motobecane bike, taking off all the components and then selling the frame on ebay. There are only two Motobecane frames on ebay at the moment and they are offered at about $500 each.

Ad mentioned that he does all of his maintenance himself. He knows how to do it and he also noted that he lives in a rural part of New Jersey; this makes trips to his local bike store difficult. He had never brought his Motobecane to a store for service so he was not sure how they would react if he did. This makes Ad an exceptional consumer: most riders at some point will need some help on something. Nevertheless, Ad is a good example of the type of consumer that is out there. Frames and Wheels also overhead a rider explaining how he had bought his Cervelo R3 on line from another individual. The rider was lamenting the recall for the fork, but I think he was satisfied overall with the purchase (I seem to recall that the frame ahd the new 3T front fork). Anyway, this exchange also supports the conclusion that cyclists are very much at ease buying their frames on line. It also occured to Frames and Wheels that consumers will forgo warranties and crash replacement programs in exhcange for a deep discount on an established and popular brand (such as Cervelo); this suggests that consumers consider carbon frames to be commodities and what they really want is to be seen as having obtained that "great deal" on that really light carbon frame. "Who cares if the thing cracks after one year; the discount was great, the ride was fast and I  can get another  one  on line any time". That is the thinking of the new consumer

Wednesday, July 28, 2010

The business plan: solving needs and wants

Consumers want the pricing, the selection and the convenience of the Internet and the community, service and support of the local IBS. The IBS wants the relationship with the customer, the option to compete with the Internet and a manageable and current inventory. The problem is that an IBS cannot compete with price and selection of the Internet: the IBS has overhead costs, labor and only so much space and capital for inventory. Meanwhile, the consumer is unable or unwilling to address maintenance issues for a bicycle and will always want to have an IBS nearby to provide support service and community. 
This condition is a function of the industry’s “push” model of production: bikes are made in very high volumes in Asia and pushed out into the distribution network each year. The IBS ties up working capital in inventory buying bikes and gear that may not be sold and that is at risk of becoming dated or obsolete as it sits on the floor. The company seeks to solve this problem by allowing the IBS to act as an agent for the company’s frames. This means that the IBS orders the frame from the company when there is a consumer who would like to buy one on hand; this is the “pull” model (Please see this post and others on frugal innovation). The IBS takes a percentage of the price and then works with the customer on choosing component groups and wheels. Ultimately, the IBS builds the bike for the consumer.  This develops the relationship between IBS and customer and it minimizes the IBS investment in inventory, which improves their cash flow. Meanwhile, the consumer obtains a high quality frame at a lower price point than what can be found at the IBS, the consumer chooses the exact components and wheels he wants or he uses his existing components and wheels; and, the consumer maintains a relationship with the local IBS. 

Thursday, July 22, 2010

Geometry comparisons to other manufacturers


Brand
F&W
Felt
Parlee
Serotta
Cervelo
Giant
Model
MCR-01
F1
Z4
HSG GS
S Series
TCR
Size
47
50
S
47
48
S
Seat tube
47.0
48.0
45.0
n/a
48.0
46.5
Top tube (e)
51.5
51.3
52.5
50.8
51.5
53.5
Head tube length
10.5
11.0
12.3
10.1
10.0
13.5
Chain stay length
41.0
41.0
41.0
n/a
39.9
40.5
Wheelbase
97.3
99.0
96.4
n/a
96.0
97.4
Head tube angle ⁰
71.0
72.0
73.0
71.0
72.5
72.0
Seat tube angle ⁰
74.5
76.0
74.0
74.0
na
73.5
BB drop
68.0
70.0
70.0
75.0
68.0
na
Stack
42.5
n/a
n/a
55.0
50.2
na
Reach
36.0
n/a
n/a
34.0
36.1
na
Stand over
n//a
73.4
74.4
74.0
70.9
74.2
Trail
n//a
n/a
n/a
n/a
na
na
BB height
n//a
n/a
n/a
n/a
20.7
na
Fork rake
4.5
4.5
4.3
5.2
na
na

Frames and Wheels compares the geometry of the MCR-01 to the geometry of some other manufacturers. The wheel base of MCR-01 is 97 cm and is comparable to the Giant TCR. Only the  Felt F1 has a longer wheelbase. The head tube angle and seat tube angle of the MCR-01 is 71 and 74.5 degrees, respectively. and the chain stay length is 41 cm and comparable to the other manufacturers. These figures imply that the frame has a slack geometry which improves stability and comfort. The head tube length is 10.5 cm and comparable to the other manufacturers except Parlee. 

The business plan: is the timing right?

I do not know the answer to this question, but I can offer the following observations: the Internet is changing the way the consumer makes purchases; consumers want the price and selection of the Internet, but the service and community of an independent bike store (IBS); the consumer is facing an extended period of slow economic growth and is more focussed on obtaining value; and, the bicycle industry is ripe for a new business model.  
The timing of this venture is right, but if anything it is too early: consumers buy their bicycles when they want them, and rarely do they buy them like they would buy a car. This is certainly true for the low and middle part of the market because the sums of money are much lower and the consumer does not really care too much about fit, components and wheels; they “want it now” because the weather is nice, their old bike is falling apart and they are satisfied with what the bike store has on the floor. However, it is even true for the high end segment of the market: the consumer is pressed for time and has a race or a triathlon coming up and they want to start training right away; they sacrifice choice and selection for immediate delivery (which is rarely  very immediate). 

The result is that the consumer buys what the IBS has on the floor which might be good enough, but not exactly what they are looking for or they order something on line, which is closer to what they want, but not necessarily right or good value. The "want it now" buyer can suffer buyer’s remorse because he spends thousands of dollars on something that is not exactly what he wants and he believes that he could have obtained a better price if he had bought it on line or at the end of the year. The "want it now" buyer can also suffer feelings of guilt and awkwardness if he buys a bicycle for thousands of dollars on line and then asks his local IBS to service it for him. The "want it now" buyer perpetuates the risky and high cost of business for the IBS: large pre-season orders of bikes that may or may not be sold; high inventory costs, high overhead costs for large spaces, etc. This model is inefficient, risky and in neither the interests of the IBS or the consumer.
Thus the challenge is educating the consumer to plan their purchase in advance and change their mind set from “want it now” to “want it right”.  It is going to take some time: the sole respondent to the poll on the blog about ordering a bicycle six months in advance was “Maybe”. Nevertheless, the Internet is moving the consumer in this direction: the consumer is bipolar and wants the best of the Internet and the local IBS. The cannot have it all, but they can have a little bit of both. Frames and Wheels believes that the high end of the market is likely to be the easier market to convince given that these consumers are more informed about what they want for components and fit.
The fact is that few if any bicycle companies sell just a frame to an IBS: they sell built up bikes because most consumers “want it now”, they have the infrastructure and the relationships to do so profitably and most IBS perhaps do not want to spend that much time building up bikes from scratch (even though they spend a lot of time preparing them once they come out of the box). Additionally, bicycle manufacturers want to be perceived as “adding value” to their frames by building them up with components of their choice (these choices are how the manufacturers segment their market into high end and middle end and low end) . They also have insights about which components will work well and safely with their frames. 

Bicycle manufacturers are not going to change their existing model in the immediate future because they have already invested so much in huge operations that generate large economies of scale and low costs per unit. In this context, the timing of the venture is again too early, but that is a good thing: existing manufacturers are beholden to the existing model and are too big to try something new.